Burning Up on Re-Entry

Tony Parker and Josh Smith

Burning Up on Re-Entry

Knox County returns more former prisoners to jail than any of Tennessee’s other metro areas. Josh Smith is pushing local leaders to break the cycle.

by jesse fox mayshark • June 18, 2021

Image
Image

state correction commissioner tony parker, left, and josh smith at the jail re-entry simulation on June 16.

Forty percent of all prisoners released in Knox County from Tennessee state prisons end up back behind bars within three years. For those released from the county jail, the number is even higher: an average of 71 percent.

Identification, jobs, housing, transportation, child support, drug tests and more challenge the recently released.

But it doesn’t have to be that way, according to Josh Smith. Both of those rates are much higher in Knox County than in any of Tennessee’s other large metropolitan areas.

“We love to lock people up,” said Smith, the Knoxville entrepreneur who sold his successful business two years ago to dedicate himself to prison reform. “We spend over a billion dollars a year in this state. There are people that are able to work, but you can't get a job because someone doesn't know how to relate to that felon or they don't know how to deal with probation and parole.”

Some places have figured out how to do a better job of easing the re-entry from incarceration back to civilian life. Shelby County, home to Memphis and some of the highest overall crime rates in the state, has recidivism rates that are less than half of Knox County’s.

That’s why Smith helped organize a jail re-entry simulation this week for about 200 local community leaders. In four separate sessions on Tuesday and Wednesday at the Junior Achievement BizTown complex in Clinton, actual state corrections employees put elected officials, business executives, nonprofit directors and others through a rapid-fire series of challenges.

The attendees included Sheriff Tom Spangler, Knoxville Police Department Chief Eve Thomas, District Attorney General Charme Allen and several members of her staff, Knoxville Mayor Indya Kincannon, and representatives of major employers in the region.

“There’s no way that we can show you the real thing,” Smith said at the start of Wednesday afternoon’s session. “But it can give you a little glimpse of what it's like for somebody when they step out of coming through incarceration, and then figuring out how to navigate life.”

No Safety Net

Simulating the first four weeks of release from custody under a variety of different conditions, the timed exercise required regular check-ins with probation officers; attendance at addiction treatment meetings; payment of child support, rent, utilities, and grocery bills; drug screenings; visits to social service agencies for help with transportation and other costs; and other challenges, any one of which was enough to throw all the others into disarray.

Missing identification can make it impossible to open a bank account. A failed drug screening could lead to a lost job, which could lead to missed child support payments, loss of food money, and eviction. Not having money to pay for transportation could mean missing a probation check-in. Any of the above could and often did land people back in front of a judge, with many sent back to jail.

“I ended up in jail three times,” Knox County Commission Chair Larsen Jay said of his experience in the simulation. “I'm a law-abiding citizen who really, I think, could navigate much of life, and it was really difficult.”

Jay worked with Smith’s 4th Purpose Foundation to organize the event, along with local business leaders Nadim Jubran and Wes Stowers. Jay said he was struck by the data showing Knox County’s perpetual high rates of recidivism.

“Everyone in this room is walking away going, ‘Wow, I had no idea how hard it was just to be a human in society,’” he said. “If we’re successful, we will have given a lot of people a much better perspective of the challenges.”

Among those on hand to guide the proceedings was state Correction Commissioner Tony Parker, who got to know Smith through both of their service on Gov. Bill Lee’s justice reform task force. Parker said he uses similar re-entry simulation training for Department of Correction staff.

“Our mission is to enhance public safety,” Parker said in an interview at Wednesday’s session. “And we believe the way to do that is for people to be successful when they re-enter society. We need to be doing everything we can to help people get their feet back under them.”

Indya Kincannon and Kyle Ward

Knoxville Mayor Indya Kincannon attempts to procure legal identification during the jail re-entry simulation, while Knox County Commissioner Kyle Ward waits behind her.

‘It’s the Community’

One point made repeatedly Wednesday was that Knox County is not currently doing that. Smith and Parker talked about successful efforts elsewhere that have no local equivalent. Shelby County, for example, has a locally funded Office of Re-Entry that provides one-stop resources for released offenders, from job placement to education access to financial literacy and health.

“I think it’s the community (that makes the difference),” Parker said. “I think community involvement and the awareness of citizens to say, what can we do to make our community healthier and safer?”

Smith said some challenges come from decades of anti-crime legislation that have introduced layer after layer of requirements and restrictions that follow people for long after they have served their time.

“As a conservative this is tough to say, but it’s our conservative legislators that are making it so tough, it’s that tough-on-crime mentality,” he said. “It’s just lock them up, and then somehow that’s going to fix (things). Whereas instead what we need to do is look at corrective behavior — how do we correct the behavior that got them in in the first place? And then how do we give them the absolute best chance to launch? But it doesn’t rest only with them. The community has to be able to accept them.”

Smith knows first-hand how hard that can be. As he recounted to the groups that went through the re-entry simulation, he served five years for drug trafficking in his 20s. When he got out, it was hard for him to find any employer willing to take a chance on a former felon. His wife and children had to move out of their government-subsidized housing because regulations forbade Smth from moving in.

“At what point should that not be a hindrance?” Smith asked the group.

He credited Lee and former Gov. Bill Haslam with helping guide some reforms through the state Legislature. One bill gave landlords immunity from liability if they rented to someone with a criminal record who then committed an offense within the building. Another provided a graduated set of consequences short of reincarceration for minor probation violations. But Smith said those allowances will help only if landlords and judges use them.

“It takes a community to change things,” he said.

Smith is putting his own money where his mouth is. His foundation is investing $3.8 million to build a set of 16 apartments on Jessamine Street in East Knoxville to provide supportive housing for men recently released from jail.

Participants gave this week’s sessions high marks. Allen, the district attorney general, said in an emailed statement, “It is important for anyone who administers justice to be aware of the challenges defendants may face when they re-enter society. Members of my office and I thought the simulation was successful in demonstrating these challenges through playing the role of someone exiting custody. A person’s ability to successfully reintegrate into the community has direct ties to public safety and recidivism. Our entire community benefits when someone can choose a life of transformation and productivity over a life of crime.”

Among those at Wednesday afternoon’s session was Knoxville Mayor Indya Kincannon. Although most of the legal responsibility for the justice system is at the state and county level, she suggested that the city could help by, for example, providing free bus passes to people being released.

“What can we do as far as transportation and housing and jobs, a lot of good ideas that came out of this with a lot of great stakeholders and leaders in our community,” Kincannon said after the session. “So I'm confident that we'll come together and remove these barriers and get people back to (being) productive members of society.”

Wrapping up the session, Smith said that was his goal.

“Over the course of two days, everybody in this community necessary to make the change to this has been here,” he said. “Everybody has been here and very fully aware that they can do that.”